This is your house, too.

Marie Eiffel Market is your local destination for fresh baked goods, organic produce, sandwiches, salads, prepared meals and catering – right here on Shelter Island. Bring our food home, or stay and relax out back enjoying our dockside water view.

Our relaxed, cool, community atmosphere is decorated with home-made everything. It’s perfect imperfection - just like a home. A quaint New York hotspot frequented by celebrities and casual foodies from all over, our store is both a reflection of the world and Marie’s taste for the curated.

Hours & Location

Real & raw - just like her ingredients.

Marie Eiffel has become a Shelter Island legend and tourist attraction. 

Born and raised in France, Marie moved to Manhattan in the early 2000s to pursue a career in consulting. A fatal car accident reincarnated her as a tastemaker, and over the past two decades, she’s earned the reputation of excellence – and being as bold as the coffee she serves.

Meet Marie

Bon appetit, to go

Our fresh and frozen foods are equally prepared with time, love, and zero preservatives.

Visit our market to shop and stock up on our selection of dishes to defrost, or place an online pickup order for a delicious, healthy meal that's ready to eat.

Order Online

  • “The food is excellent! We ate just about everything they offer, and we would be delighted to come back and eat the rest!” - Christie Brinkley

  • “I wish I had snapped a picture of the pain au Chocolat, but I ate it so fast, and then I was really sad because it was gone… Or maybe it was all a mirage, and I dreamed up the best croissant I've had on this side of the Atlantic.” - Meera Dave

  • “Marie Eiffel is a brilliant baker, as proven by her flourless chocolate cake and peach torte. Add to that a good cheese, fresh fruit and vegetable selection, and you have a top-notch market for the sophisticated urban visitor.” - Bob S

  • “I love this place. The coffee is good, and Marie is meticulous about her food and merchandise. The Blanxart chocolate bars are my favorite, but her house-made pastries and treats are fantastic.” - Michael Dollar

  • “Shelter Island would be a less vital place without Marie Eiffel’s Market. We go every day for delicious coffee, great sandwiches (crab cake, lobster roll, egg sandwich), yummy omelets, soups, world class desserts and pastries. Extraordinary quality, great, lively, chic atmosphere, wonderful for all ages, all tastes, all day! Sure it’s a bit pricey, but it’s worth it!” - Jim F

  • “Best of the best yummy French food. The roast chicken OMG and duck wow, oh and the lamb is wonderful. The fresh produce is fragrant and delicious. Then there’s the cold box with containers of ready made delicious foods and salads. YUM YUM YUM!" - Scott Goodson

1 6